Like so many of the films and plays written and sometimes directed by David Mamet (House of Games, Glengarry Glen Ross), Homicide is an acquired taste. The artificial yet somehow riveting dialogue, the characters who seem to narrate their own actions like role-playing children, the vague sense that the audience is being conned just like one of those characters: These elements scream "Mamet!" and nothing else. That said, 1991's Homicide works surprisingly well as a taut, suspenseful police thriller. It bogs down a bit once the mind games begin, but little harm results.
For Homicide's debut on this DVD-only release, Criterion's treatment suits the subject well. Unlike so many studio-produced discs, this release retains some of the movie's film grain, as well as the appropriately muted colors of its urban setting. The original 2-channel sound is sparse but crisp. A new 20-minute documentary features Mamet's "guys from Chicago," the five or so actors (led here by Joe Mantegna) who seem to appear in each of his works. Amusingly, and despite all their best efforts, they fail to explain what makes the Mamet thing so compelling. A relaxed, unpredictable, and agenda-free commentary by Mamet and William H. Macy round out the package nicely. Download Homicide full movie (DVD,DivX,iPod,PDA)